Review form for TMA-2010 CFP available from http://www.pam2010.ethz.ch/TMA/ Title of the paper: Authors: --------------------------REVIEW QUESTIONS-------------- For each review request delete all the rows except the one matching your choice. *Technical correcteness* Is the work technically sound ? 1 - Strong Reject 2 - Reject 3 - Weak Reject 4 - Neutral 5 - Weak Accept 6 - Accept 7 - Strong Accept *Relevance to the CFP* Is the paper in the scope of the TMA Workshop ? 1 - Strong Reject 2 - Reject 3 - Weak Reject 4 - Neutral 5 - Weak Accept 6 - Accept 7 - Strong Accept *Quality of presentation* Does the paper clearly presents the problem, method and results ? 1 - Strong Reject 2 - Reject 3 - Weak Reject 4 - Neutral 5 - Weak Accept 6 - Accept 7 - Strong Accept *Novel insight, originality* How much novel insight is provided by the paper ? Does it deliver original results, methods or findings ? 1 - Strong Reject 2 - Reject 3 - Weak Reject 4 - Neutral 5 - Weak Accept 6 - Accept 7 - Strong Accept *Potential impact, interest* How much interest would rise in the community of experts (researchers and practitioners) ? What is the potential impact ? 1 - Strong Reject 2 - Reject 3 - Weak Reject 4 - Neutral 5 - Weak Accept 6 - Accept 7 - Strong Accept *Overall Recommendation* 1 - Strong Reject 2 - Reject 3 - Weak Reject 4 - Neutral 5 - Weak Accept 6 - Accept 7 - Strong Accept *Reviewer's expertise* 1 - Low 2 - Medium 3 - High *Summary of contribution (shown to the authors)* *Detailed comments (shown to the authors)* *Which topic of the call for paper does this paper address? Please, SELECT the topic from the CFP, or state NONE.* * Report on independent validation or critical revision of earlier works on traffic analysis and network measurements; * Provide technology and material to enable and promote validation works, e.g. shared datasets, tools, collaborative platforms etc. * Report on hands-on lessons learned and operational experience gained with performing measurement/monitoring in a real network setting, e.g. discuss practical problems and workarounds in large-scale monitoring campaigns for production use. * Define methodologies for collecting and analyzing measurements in different network environments (wireless and wired infrastructures, sensor, social networks). * Propose benchmarking methodologies to compare competing solution in the field of traffic analysis. Describe Open Software tools for supporting measurement collection and validation, analysis and modeling. * Define techniques for improving the repeatability of tests, benchmarks, and validation studies. * Propose novel measurement and analysis techniques while providing all the necessary material for independent validation (tools, data sets, etc.). *Comments for Program Committee (not shown to the authors)* *Name of External Reviewer*